Abortions
should not be allowed, except...?
 |
|
Hand of a
21-week old fetus that fell out of the womb
The doctor is placing the hand back in the womb.
The fetus underwent an
operation for spina bifida |
 |
|
The fetus
became Samuel Alexander Armas.
He wasn't, but suppose little
Samuel
had been conceived
due to a rape?
|
In this essay, I'm using
the word "abortion" to refer to surgery to remove an embryo or fetus
that, if left within the woman, would be born as a child. I am not
referring to surgery to remove dead tissue that can not, under any
condition, be born as a child.
Even
though they oppose abortions, many people make exceptions for situations
in which the pregnancies occurred due to incest or rape or impose a danger to
the life of the mother. In doing this,
they are saying that abortions are acceptable in some situations but not
in other situations. This attitude toward exceptions concerns me.
I've
heard people who oppose abortions give three reasons why abortions should
not be performed. Some people believe that embryos and fetuses are human
beings and that abortions are murder. Other people say that abortions are
not murder, but abortions should not be performed because the embryos or
fetuses contain unique patterns of DNA and are thus unique themselves;
these unique growths should not be killed. A third group says that
abortions should not be performed, because the embryos and fetuses are
future homes of God's spirit children. If abortions occur, the spirits
will have to occupy different bodies than they would have occupied, and
the plans of God will be thwarted.
In
the case of unique DNA patterns or future homes for
spirits, I don't see a conflict with allowing abortions in cases of incest
or rape or danger to the mother. However, in the case of murder, I am concerned about any
exceptions for abortions. If it is wrong to perform abortions that commit
murder when incest and rape are not involved and the abortions do not present a
danger to the mother, why is it OK to perform
abortions that commit murder when incest or rape is involved or the abortions
present a danger to the mother? Surely, we
are not saying that murder is permissible in some situations but not in
other situations! If abortions are murder, then the
woman faces a difficult question that, I believe, only the woman can answer
-- should murder be committed to save her life, or is she willing to give up her
life to save the life of her baby. The woman's dilemma, our dilemma, of
course, is that we do not know if those embryos and fetuses are human
beings. We do not know when a spirit child of God enters a body and
becomes a soul. I oppose abortions because I believe we should not take
risks that abortions might be murder. If we make errors in judgment about
abortions, I want those errors to favor human life.